[cmd3] Enforce command lifetimes across all opmode and command scopes (#8705)

Commands are no longer able to outlive their schedule-site's scope,
regardless of how they were scheduled (set as a default command, bound
to a trigger, or manually scheduled)

As a consequence, default commands need better tracking so the default
command setting can be released when their scope exits and the next-most
appropriate default command can be rescheduled (eg, an opmode sets a
default command, then the globally-scoped default is restored when the
opmode exits). Some complexity is required here to make it work well for
edge cases.

Like `schedule()`, `setDefaultCommand()` will immediately start the new
default command if called inside of another command to avoid 1-loop
delays. However, this does not apply when called by the _current_
default command, as it would result in attempting to cancel the default
command while it's mounted (which is impossible and would throw an
exception)

```java
class Robot extends OpModeRobot {
  final Drive drive = new Drive();
  final CommandXboxController controller = new CommandXboxController(1);

  public Robot() {
    // global default command, active unless overridden in an opmode or command
    drive.setDefaultCommand(drive.stop());

    // global trigger binding, always active
    controller.rightBumper().onTrue(drive.setX());
  }
}

@Teleop
class ExampleOpMode extends PeriodicOpMode {
  public ExampleOpMode(Robot robot) {
    // opmode-specific default command
    robot.drive.setDefaultCommand(robot.drive.operatorControl(robot.controller));

    // opmode-specific binding
    robot.controller.leftBumper().whileTrue(robot.drive.stop());

    // opmode-specific binding that takes precedence over the global binding
    // because it happens last; it "wins out" over the `setX()` binding
    robot.controller.rightBumper().onTrue(robot.drive.selfTest());
  }

  @Override
  public void periodic() {
    Scheduler.getDefault().run();
  }
}
```
This commit is contained in:
Sam Carlberg
2026-04-09 20:05:42 -04:00
committed by GitHub
parent 5a96685c86
commit 02c6030251
23 changed files with 677 additions and 82 deletions

View File

@@ -159,6 +159,7 @@ struct Instance {
// Op mode lookup
wpi::util::mutex opModeMutex;
wpi::util::DenseMap<int64_t, HAL_OpModeOption> opModes;
bool userProgramStarted = false;
wpi::units::second_t nextMessageTime = 0_s;
@@ -679,7 +680,24 @@ void DriverStation::ClearOpModes() {
HAL_SetOpModeOptions(nullptr, 0);
}
void DriverStation::ObserveUserProgramStarting() {
::GetInstance().userProgramStarted = true;
HAL_ObserveUserProgramStarting();
}
int64_t DriverStation::GetOpModeId() {
if (!::GetInstance().userProgramStarted) {
return 0;
}
return GetControlWord().GetOpModeId();
}
std::string DriverStation::GetOpMode() {
if (!::GetInstance().userProgramStarted) {
return 0;
}
return GetInstance().OpModeToString(GetOpModeId());
}

View File

@@ -117,13 +117,14 @@ void OpModeRobotBase::StartCompetition() {
// Wait for new data from the driver station, with 50 ms timeout
HAL_SetNotifierAlarm(m_notifier, 50000, 0, false, true, &status);
// Call HAL_ObserveUserProgramStarting() here as a one-shot to ensure it is
// called after the notifier alarm is set. The notifier alarm is set using
// relative time, so tests that wait on the user program to start and then
// step time won't work correctly if we call this before setting the alarm.
// Call DriverStation::ObserveUserProgramStarting() here as a one-shot to
// ensure it is called after the notifier alarm is set. The notifier alarm
// is set using relative time, so tests that wait on the user program to
// start and then step time won't work correctly if we call this before
// setting the alarm.
if (!calledObserveUserProgramStarting) {
calledObserveUserProgramStarting = true;
HAL_ObserveUserProgramStarting();
DriverStation::ObserveUserProgramStarting();
}
auto signaled = wpi::util::WaitForObjects(events, signaledBuf);

View File

@@ -9,7 +9,7 @@
#include <cstdio>
#include <utility>
#include "wpi/hal/DriverStation.h"
#include "wpi/driverstation/DriverStation.hpp"
#include "wpi/hal/Notifier.hpp"
#include "wpi/hal/UsageReporting.hpp"
#include "wpi/system/Errors.hpp"
@@ -23,7 +23,7 @@ void TimedRobot::StartCompetition() {
// Tell the DS that the robot is ready to be enabled
std::puts("\n********** Robot program startup complete **********");
HAL_ObserveUserProgramStarting();
DriverStation::ObserveUserProgramStarting();
// Loop forever, calling the appropriate mode-dependent function
while (true) {

View File

@@ -454,6 +454,20 @@ class DriverStation final {
*/
static void ClearOpModes();
/**
* Sets the program starting flag in the DS. This will also allow
* getOpModeId() and getOpMode() to return values for the selected
* OpMode in the DS application, if the DS is connected by the time this
* method is called.
*
* <p>Most users will not need to use this method; the TimedRobot and
* OpModeRobot robot framework classes will call it automatically after
* the main robot class is instantiated.
*
* <p>This is what changes the DS to showing robot code ready.
*/
static void ObserveUserProgramStarting();
/**
* Gets the operating mode selected on the driver station. Note this does not
* mean the robot is enabled; use IsEnabled() for that. In a match, this will
@@ -464,7 +478,7 @@ class DriverStation final {
* @return the unique ID provided by the AddOpMode() function; may return 0 or
* a unique ID not added, so callers should be prepared to handle that case
*/
static int64_t GetOpModeId() { return GetControlWord().GetOpModeId(); }
static int64_t GetOpModeId();
/**
* Gets the operating mode selected on the driver station. Note this does not